
Because my BS-o-meter is in overdrive this morning, as I churn out a paper on post-9/11 performance art, I'll take up QB's challenge to address the Moz Debate.
I can't find the original NME article, but the
BBC News quote below says it all:
The magazine quoted Morrissey allegedly saying: "Although I don't have anything against people from other countries, the higher the influx into England the more the British identity disappears. So the price is enormous."
"If you travel to Germany, it's still absolutely Germany. If you travel to Sweden, it still has a Swedish identity. But travel to England and you have no idea where you are," the singer is reported to have said.
Our beloved Mozzy is no stranger to accusations of 'isms" (see "National Front Disco" and "Cemetery Gates"). I can't help but think, however, that NME is being overly PC in their criticism of the comments above.
Morrissey's defense is that he has issued statements of fact. I agree. These are facts. There's a lot of immigration in England. The "Essential Englishness" of days past is long gone. "Englishness" itself has changed in response to the influx of new cultural influences into Britain. Is immigration a bad thing, no. Is new cultural mixing a bad thing, no. But is the Englishness of the past gone? Well, yes. Is that a "loss"? Sure it is.
What I'm not quite sure about is when exactly Morrissey began to sense this loss. After World War II, the Center for Contemporary Cultural Studies was established in Birmingham to preserve male, British working class culture. Now, the CCCS studies the changes in British culture due to factors such as immigration (see the work of Stuart Hall, Paul Gilroy, Kobena Mercer). So we have academics who trace this loss of "Essential Englishness" to the postwar era and are now studying new cultural shifts. Maybe Morrissey is missing 1940s British working man culture (who knows, that might get him excited, no?), but it seems more like he's being nostalgic for some sort of fictitious version of "Englishness" that never existed in the first place.
Furthermore, I'm irked by the fact that people do not acknowledge that, historically at least, what constitutes "Englishness" was predicated on the existence of colonies. Colonial subjects are the Others against which the English derived a sense of superiority and, in truth, a sense of what being "English" even meant.
So there's no crime in what Morrissey said. It's statement, pure and simple. I would question, though, his use of "English" because it's a reflection of the same ignorance shared by many Brits. Is that a crime? Well, maybe. But should the NME apologize to our beloved Moz? Yes, they should. And while they're at it, they should apologize for being British too, because it's England that's largely responsible for the bloody mess that world is right now.
And you can't disagree with me because I'm an immigrant and have the final say ;-)