April 06, 2007

Debate.

'up the bracket' vs 'the libertines'.





'bracket'. a raw, tumble mess of gorgeous songs. the standouts: 'time for heroes', 'boys in the band', 'i get along', 'what a waster', 'begging' and -- my personal favorite -- 'the good old days':

If you've lost your faith in love and music
Oh, the end won't be long


and then there are the second-tier songs that any The View or Arctic Monkeys should be grateful to have on their record: 'vertigo', 'horrorshow' and 'death on the stairs', for example.

'the libertines'. it's the morning after, and things aren't quite as rosy. the agita of being The Next Big Thing has set in.

The arcadian dream, so fallen through...

but agita makes for great music. because pete and carl are having a wee bit of trouble being in the same room. 'can't stand me now'. hmm, no subtleties there. 'narcissist': a bit of ego-jabbing. 'likely lads': what became of the dreams we had? we'll never know.

'music when the lights go out', 'last post on the bugle': libertines light, but tasty. even 'what katie did': sure, cheesy, but carl sings it so tentatively, you want to cheer him on.

and then there's 'france'. sigh. who doesn't want to be that 'ideal girl' who leaves him entranced?

i give this one to 'bracket' by a margin, but it was close. feel free to argue.

[we'll not venture into b-sides and demos tonight. though, if pressed, i'll pick 'you're my waterloo' and 'breck road lover', both from the odessa studio recordings, as two of the best.]



In homage: Peter and Carl on "What Sadie Did Next". Watch Carl cringe when Pete asks Sadie if she's gotten off with Carl. Actually, feel free to cringe every time Sadie opens her mouth.

4 comments:

CyFlorist said...

I'll have say, 'Up the Bracket' song-wise, but 'The Libertines' wins for best cover art.


Mmmm, Carlos in a hat. It's too bad that I've decided that my next "true love" is Mr. Meighan. The dimples were too much to resist.

Yes, QB, Carl is all yours again.

Thinking Fish said...

I dunno, 'Up the Bracket' is the album at their most idealistic, young, loaded with kick-ass songs and everything to prove.

'The Libertines' is bitter, darker, as you say QB, more a documentary.

But for me, when all is said and done, you stand or fall on the songs, and 'Bracket' winds because the strength of the band was always Pete and Carl together. Unlike say Massive Attack, where the internal fighting produced a more sublime quality that couldn't have been achieved any other way, Carl and Pete's struggles took away from the music rather than adding.

On the upside, what carl and Pete share is that they work better on the back foot...well, as long as Pete can stay on his feet long enough anyway.

Miss Odd Bee said...

I always felt that Up The Bracket was better because it was rougher.

CyFlorist said...

Odd, don't use the word 'rough' in reference to The Libs. My mind goes to very bad places.